SEO strategies come and go, but one question still lingers: is it worth disavowing toxic backlinks? With Google’s algorithm becoming increasingly sophisticated at recognizing spammy or manipulative link patterns, many marketers and webmasters are rethinking their approach to disavow files.
On the surface, disavowing unwanted links might feel like a proactive move – an easy way to “clean up” your link profile. But how necessary is it today, really?
Google Is Smarter Than Ever – But Not Perfect
Google’s systems have grown much better at ignoring links from obvious spam networks, poor-quality directories, and shady domains. In many cases, these links are simply devalued and won’t negatively affect your site. So if your link profile includes a few odd links from obscure domains or old spammy blog comments, chances are they’re not doing much damage – or much of anything at all.
However, there are exceptions. In certain scenarios, taking the time to disavow links can still be a worthwhile move.
When Disavowing Might Make Sense
- Manual Actions: If your site has received a manual action for unnatural links, disavowing is essential. This is one of the rare times Google explicitly recommends using the tool.
- Aggressive Past Link Building: If you’re working with a site that had aggressive SEO practices in the past – especially involving paid links, PBNs, or keyword-stuffed anchor text – it’s worth auditing the link profile and considering a disavow to distance yourself from those tactics.
- Negative SEO Campaigns: While rare, negative SEO attacks (sudden influxes of toxic, foreign, or anchor-spammed backlinks) can still occur, particularly in highly competitive industries. Disavowing such links may help mitigate any potential risks, even if it’s mostly as a preventive measure.
The Pitfalls of Over-Disavowing
There’s a risk in going overboard. Many automated tools label links as “toxic” based on algorithmic scores that don’t align with how Google actually evaluates them. Removing too many links – or the wrong ones – can do more harm than good by weakening your link equity.
It’s also important to remember that disavowing links is not a ranking booster. It’s a safeguard, not a growth strategy. At best, it can prevent issues; it won’t push your rankings higher.
So… Should You Still Use It?
Disavow remains a tool in the SEO toolbox – but not one you pull out for every little thing. So it’s not like duct tape :-) Think of it like insurance: you don’t use it unless you see real risk. If you understand what you’re doing, it probably won’t hurt. But blindly trusting third-party toxicity scores or aggressively pruning your link profile can be counterproductive.
Final Thoughts
For most websites in 2025, regular monitoring, high-quality content, and natural link-building efforts are a far better use of your time than obsessing over every questionable backlink. But in cases where link spam is persistent or legacy SEO tactics may pose a risk, the disavow tool still has its place – quietly waiting in the background when you really need it.
Related: What Makes Your Website Content “High-Quality Content”? We Spill the Tea!
What is the best strategy to get high-quality SEO backlinks?
How to Leverage Broken Link Building to Get High-Quality Backlinks for Your Website
Should You Buy High DA Backlinks? The Truth Behind Backlinks and What Really Moves the SEO Needle
Ready to design & build your own website? Learn more about UltimateWB! We also offer web design packages if you would like your website designed and built for you.
Got a techy/website question? Whether it’s about UltimateWB or another website builder, web hosting, or other aspects of websites, just send in your question in the “Ask David!” f