Amazon just made history – and not in the way it wanted. The company has agreed to pay $2.5 billion to settle a case with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which accused the e-commerce giant of tricking millions of people into signing up for Prime memberships and making cancellation a confusing nightmare.
This is the largest FTC settlement of its kind, and it could change the way subscription services operate going forward. Here’s what happened, who gets refunds, and what it means for the future of digital subscriptions.
Why the FTC Went After Amazon
The FTC said Amazon used “dark patterns” – sneaky design tricks that nudge people into actions they might not otherwise take.
- Prime sign-up confusion: Customers thought they were checking out with free shipping, but in reality, they were being enrolled in a paid Prime membership.
- Cancellation maze: Once enrolled, leaving wasn’t easy. Users were pushed through multiple screens and prompts that discouraged cancellation. Internally, Amazon even called the cancellation process “Project Iliad” – a nod to the famously long and difficult journey.
The FTC argued this violated U.S. consumer protection laws, and Amazon ultimately chose settlement over trial.
What the Settlement Includes
- $1 billion in civil penalties (the largest fine of its type ever).
- $1.5 billion for consumer refunds.
- Automatic refunds of $51 for certain Prime members who were misled between 2019 and 2025.
- Simplified cancellation flows – no more “endless clicks” to quit.
- Clearer disclosures about what you’re signing up for and how much it costs.
- Oversight by an independent monitor to make sure Amazon plays by the new rules.
Who Gets Refunds – and How
Roughly 35 million customers could be eligible for money back.
- If you signed up for Prime during the disputed period and didn’t use many Prime perks, you’ll likely get $51 automatically.
- Others can file claims if they feel they were misled or blocked from canceling.
- Amazon will notify eligible customers within 30 days, and refunds should go out within 90 days.
Why This Matters Beyond Amazon
This settlement is about more than just Prime – it’s a signal to all subscription-based companies.
- “Dark patterns” are out: Companies can no longer hide behind tricky checkout buttons or endless cancellation loops.
- Subscription reform is coming: From streaming services to SaaS tools, regulators are watching closely.
- Consumers win: Easier opt-outs and more transparency are now expected, not optional.
Final Take
Amazon’s $2.5 billion settlement is a wake-up call for Big Tech. For customers, it means refunds, easier cancellations, and fewer tricks at checkout. For companies, it’s a warning shot: deceptive design could cost you billions.
👉 If you’ve had a Prime membership since 2019, keep an eye on your inbox – you might have cash coming your way.
💻 Ready to build a website on your terms? No dark patterns with UltimateWB. Pass on the same awesome experience to your customers. With UltimateWB, you can design it yourself or choose one of our web design packages – we’ll build it for you.
Got a techy/website question? Whether it’s about UltimateWB or another website builder, web hosting, or other aspects of websites, just send in your question in the “Ask David!” form. We will email you when the answer is posted on the UltimateWB “Ask David!” section.