GoFundMe was in damage-control mode last week after sparking outrage from nonprofits nationwide. The crowdfunding platform quietly created fundraising pages for more than a million organizations – without ever asking their permission.
The company says the idea was to make it easier for people to donate to verified charities. But many nonprofits were shocked to discover they suddenly had a public GoFundMe page they never made, complete with donation buttons and descriptions pulled from third-party data sources.
The Problem
Around 1.4 million organizations were affected. These auto-generated pages were live, searchable, and in some cases even optimized for Google – all without the nonprofits knowing they existed.
Some groups worried donors might think the pages were official partnerships. Others said the listings included outdated or incorrect information. For organizations that depend on transparency and direct relationships with supporters, the move felt like a serious breach of trust.
The National Council of Nonprofits publicly criticized GoFundMe, saying that while the intention may have been good, the execution crossed a clear line: consent. Nonprofits, they said, should always have control over how and where they fundraise online.
GoFundMe’s Apology
After days of backlash, GoFundMe admitted it “missed the mark.” In an apology posted on October 23, the company said:
“We understand clearly that our recent efforts with Nonprofit Pages have caused confusion, concern, and distraction. We are very sorry for this and take responsibility.”
The company promised to make things right by:
- Making nonprofit pages opt-in only, so they won’t appear online without the organization’s approval.
- Removing or de-indexing any pages that were created automatically.
- Stopping SEO promotion for unclaimed pages.
Why It Matters
This might sound like a simple misunderstanding, but it taps into something bigger happening across the tech world. More companies are relying on automation and public data to “fill in the blanks” – sometimes without thinking about consent.
In this case, GoFundMe used data to build out new features. But by doing so without clear permission, it blurred the line between innovation and overreach. For nonprofits, it’s not just a matter of principle – it’s about protecting their reputation, donor trust, and financial transparency.
The Bigger Picture
The GoFundMe controversy is a perfect example of how good intentions in tech can go sideways. Automation can make things faster and more efficient, but it can also strip people and organizations of control over their own presence online.
In the rush to innovate, companies sometimes forget that trust isn’t built by algorithms – it’s built by people.
GoFundMe’s quick apology and promise to change direction show that the company understands that now. But it also serves as a warning to every tech platform: ask first, automate later.
Ready to design & build your own community website? Learn more about UltimateWB! We also offer web design packages if you would like your website designed and built for you.
Got a techy/website question? Whether it’s about UltimateWB or another website builder, web hosting, or other aspects of websites, just send in your question in the “Ask David!” form. We will email you when the answer is posted on the UltimateWB “Ask David!” section.